Stories

The Strange True Stories Behind Famous Paintings

A painting changes the moment you know what happened to it. Seven masterpieces, and the thefts, scandals, accidents and obsessions hiding behind them.

You can stand in front of a painting and see nothing but paint. Then someone tells you that the canvas was once bigger, or that it was stolen, or that the man in the corner is the artist himself, daring you to find him. Suddenly the surface cracks open and the whole thing starts to breathe.

The truth behind a famous painting is almost never the polite version printed on the museum label. It is messier, funnier, and often more violent than that. These seven pictures carry stories of theft, scandal, mental collapse, and obsessive labor. Once you know them, you cannot unsee them.

The Night Watch

The painting you see today is smaller than the one Rembrandt made, because somebody took a knife to it to make it fit a wall.

Rembrandt's enormous group portrait of a militia company was never meant to be called The Night Watch. That nickname came later, when layers of darkened varnish made the scene look like it took place at night. It is actually broad daylight. The real title is something closer to The Militia Company of District II under the Command of Captain Frans Banninck Cocq.

In 1715 the canvas was moved to Amsterdam's town hall and, to fit between two doors, it was simply trimmed down on all four sides. The largest cut came off the left, removing two figures and throwing off Rembrandt's careful composition. The original dimensions survive only in an old copy. The painting you admire now is a cropped version of a lost original.

It has also been attacked three times. In 1911 a man slashed at it with a shoemaker's knife. In 1975 an unemployed teacher cut deep zigzag gashes into the canvas. And in 1990 a visitor sprayed it with acid, though guards rinsed it with water before the acid reached the paint layer. The wounds were repaired, but if you know where to look, the restorations are part of its history now.

See it now: Notice how Captain Cocq stands oddly close to the left edge, with space stolen from him by the 1715 cut, and look for the bright little girl glowing in the crowd like she is lit from inside.

Mona Lisa

The most famous painting on Earth became famous because a handyman walked out of the Louvre with it under his coat.

For centuries the Mona Lisa was admired but not worshipped. It was one celebrated Leonardo among many. That changed on August 21, 1911, when an Italian handyman named Vincenzo Peruggia, who had actually worked at the Louvre, hid in a closet overnight, lifted the painting off the wall the next morning, removed it from its frame in a stairwell, and walked out with it tucked under his smock.

The theft was not even noticed for over a day. The empty space on the wall drew bigger crowds than the painting ever had. Newspapers ran the story worldwide, and the missing Mona Lisa became a global obsession. Even Pablo Picasso was briefly questioned by police. For two years the painting was simply gone.

Peruggia kept it hidden in his Paris apartment, reportedly in a false-bottomed trunk, before trying to sell it to a dealer in Florence in 1913. He claimed he was a patriot returning the work to Italy, though Leonardo had taken it to France himself. He was caught, served a short sentence, and the painting toured Italy before going home to the Louvre. The theft, not the brushwork, is what turned her into a legend.

See it now: Look past the bulletproof glass and the crowds at her hands, calmly folded, and remember that those same hands were once rolled up in a workman's smock on a Paris street.

The Scream

There is a tiny pencil message hidden on the canvas that reads: could only have been painted by a madman.

The Scream is not one painting but a family of them. Munch created several versions in paint, pastel, and print between 1893 and 1910, all showing the same hairless figure clutching its face against a blood-orange sky. Munch said the idea came to him during a walk at sunset, when he felt an infinite scream passing through nature.

In the upper left corner of one painted version, written faintly in pencil, is a Norwegian inscription that translates to could only have been painted by a madman. For years scholars debated whether a vandal wrote it or Munch did. Recent analysis of the handwriting concluded that the words are almost certainly Munch's own, likely a bitter response to a critic who publicly suggested he was mentally unwell.

The images have also been irresistible to thieves. In 1994 one version was stolen from the National Gallery in Oslo during the Winter Olympics, with the thieves leaving a note thanking the gallery for the poor security. It was recovered months later. In 2004 armed robbers seized another version, along with Munch's Madonna, in a daylight raid on the Munch Museum. Both were recovered in 2006, slightly damaged but intact.

See it now: Notice that the screaming figure is not screaming at all but covering its ears, trying to shut out a scream coming from the world itself.

Olympia

When this nude went on public display, the crowds got so hostile the painting had to be guarded by police.

Paris was used to nudes. The Salon walls were full of them. What scandalized viewers about Olympia when it was shown in 1865 was that Manet refused to dress his nude up as a goddess or a nymph. She was unmistakably a real, modern woman, a courtesan, looking straight out at the viewer with cool, unbothered confidence.

Every detail was a provocation. The black ribbon around her neck, the single slipper dangling off her foot, the bouquet brought by a maid that suggested a client had just arrived. Critics were appalled. They called the painting indecent and ugly, attacked its flat lighting and harsh outlines, and described her body in cruel terms. Some visitors reportedly tried to strike the canvas with their canes or umbrellas.

The hostility grew so intense that the painting was rehung high on a wall, out of reach, and guards were posted to protect it. Manet was devastated by the reaction. Yet Olympia is now seen as a turning point toward modern art, precisely because it told the truth about who this woman was instead of hiding it behind mythology.

See it now: Meet her gaze, because that direct, level stare is exactly what enraged the 1865 crowds, and notice the maid and the flowers hinting at the man who has just walked in: you.

The Starry Night

Van Gogh painted this swirling night sky from the window of the asylum room where he had voluntarily committed himself.

In May 1889, after a series of breakdowns including the episode in which he cut off part of his own ear, Van Gogh checked himself into the Saint-Paul-de-Mausole asylum in Saint-Remy-de-Provence. From a barred window in his room he could see the countryside and the rolling hills, and at dawn one June morning he painted the view of the sky.

But The Starry Night is not a literal record. The night sky pulses and churns with energy that no telescope ever showed. The cypress tree in the foreground rises like a dark flame. And the village nestled below, with its tall church spire, is largely invented. There was no such village visible from his window. The spire owes more to the churches of his native Netherlands than to anything in southern France.

Van Gogh painted it during the day, from memory and imagination, blending what he saw with what he felt. He was oddly unsure about it, even calling such studies a failure in letters to his brother Theo. It has since become one of the most recognized paintings in human history, made by a man who sold almost nothing in his lifetime and died the following year.

See it now: Look at the cypress in the foreground reaching up toward the turbulent sky, a dark living thing connecting the troubled earth to the stars, and remember a window with bars was just out of frame.

Whistler's Mother

The world's most famous portrait of a mother only happened because a different model failed to show up.

The painting everyone calls Whistler's Mother was given a far colder title by the artist himself: Arrangement in Grey and Black No. 1. Whistler cared more about the harmony of tones and shapes than about sentiment. He insisted the picture was an arrangement of color, and that the identity of the sitter should be of no interest to the public.

The sitter, of course, was very much his actual mother, Anna McNeill Whistler. The story goes that Whistler had planned to paint a young model who did not turn up, so his mother offered to pose instead. He had originally intended to paint her standing, but the elderly woman could not hold the pose, so she sat, and one of the most iconic compositions in art was born out of practical necessity.

The French state bought it in 1891, a rare honor for an American artist, and it now hangs in the Musee d'Orsay. Despite Whistler's protests about sentiment, the image became a worldwide symbol of motherhood, even appearing on a United States postage stamp in 1934. The cold abstraction he wanted is exactly the thing people warmed to.

See it now: Notice how she is shown in strict profile, more shape than person, a study in grey and black, and yet the whole world insists on feeling something about her anyway.

A Sunday Afternoon on the Island of La Grande Jatte

This calm scene of park-goers is built from millions of tiny separate dots, and it took Seurat about two years to make.

Georges Seurat did not mix his colors on a palette the way painters had for centuries. Instead he placed countless tiny dots and dashes of pure, unmixed color side by side, trusting the viewer's eye to blend them from a distance. He called his method something close to chromoluminarism. We now call it pointillism, and Seurat was its inventor.

The Grande Jatte was a real island in the Seine just outside Paris, a popular spot for Parisians to stroll on Sundays. Seurat spent roughly two years on the canvas, making dozens of preliminary sketches and color studies before applying the final layers, dot by patient dot, across a surface more than ten feet wide. He even added a painted border of dots so the frame would not break the optical effect.

The result is strange and still, like the figures have been frozen in a quiet, geometric trance. When it was shown in 1886 it baffled and divided critics, some seeing a scientific breakthrough and others seeing cold, lifeless mannequins. Today it hangs in the Art Institute of Chicago, and standing close to it you see only specks, while stepping back assembles a whole sunlit world.

See it now: Walk up close until the figures dissolve into pure colored dots, then step back and watch them snap into shimmering form, the exact trick Seurat spent two years engineering.

None of these stories changes the paint on the canvas. The strokes are the same as they always were. What changes is you, the looker, suddenly carrying the theft and the scandal and the asylum window in your head as you stand there. A painting is never just an object on a wall. It is the surviving evidence of a human life, with all its accidents and obsessions still trapped inside the frame. Look again, and look closer.

Next: the field guide to art movements →